Pizzeria Fifty Four

Reviews

• Greg S.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  A good pizzeria in Albany, cash only, but an ATM is in the restaurant. Good, standard pizza. I got two slices with pepperoni and sausage. Good sauce, crunchy crust. Just a minute walk from the Palace Theater, if you need a good pizza fix, this will do it.

• Benjamin M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 27 May 2026

  I came here (actually, wandered into here) late in the afternoon while searching for something else. I figured it might be worth a try as I hadn't eaten lunch today. They had several pizzas out for buying by the slice, as well as sausage and peppers, calzones, etc. I ordered a slice of the pepperoni and sausage pizza. It was reheated to a piping hot temperature which melted the plastic fork (!) into a bent mangled utensil. However, as I like my pizza hot no complaints here. It cost $3.
  
  The pizza was lousy. I don't know if it was because it was sitting around for a long time, but the crust was extremely dry and lacking any flavor. The crust still had white flour all over it, and it lacked salt. The sauce was missing an acidic or sweet flavor component. There was plenty of cheese, but it was one-dimensional taste wise. The pepperoni was crispy (and unfortunately really greasy) but the sausage was cut into thin strips and added nothing to the pizza. It could have been missing. I am left with a flour taste in my mouth and a grease ball in my stomach.
  
  Perhaps I caught them on a bad day?

• Alexis L.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 26 May 2026

  I have never had such a horrible experience at a business before in my life. When ordering my slice of pizza the employee asked me why my voice was so raspy and I responded with telling him I am unsure it happens to me quite often. Excuse me for this horrible language, but the employee responded back to me by saying "I know the real reason your voice is so raspy, you've been deep throating too many dicks." I have never been so utterly disrespected and disgusted before in my life. On top of receiving such a horrible demeaning comment my debit card was charged $63 for ONE slice of pizza. Do not ever bring your business there, this was such a disgusting experience for me and do not wish for this to happen to anyone else.

• Tenesia B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Happy humpday! So I'm here in the office, figured I'd have an Italian sub for brunch (breakfast for champions) delivered to me. After waiting 1.5 hours... I received the call that my food had arrived. The Italian sub definitely lacks the Italian combination of meats that I was hoping to enjoy but I do like the bread.

• Florence V.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 17 May 2026

  I'm giving away my one star because this was an easy place close-by where we could get our hands on food to fill our stomachs when me and my group were hungry and freezing - it was close by to the bar we partied. Person at the cashier deceitfully charged me $7 for a $5 bill. Which she of course said, "$5". Pizza + bottled water. Of course, I found out the next day. If anyone wants to waste their money on deceitfully greasy food, well, ladies and gentlemen I bring you this pizzeria.